A Call to End Religious Nutrition

lowcarbQ: “How can you tell if a friend is on a gluten-free diet?”

A: “They’ll tell you.”

Again and again and again… Same joke goes for paleo, low-carbvegan and pretty much any organized dietary strategy that has a defining name and movement behind it.

Along with politics, gun rights, religion and abortion, is one of those areas where people feel comfortable not only sharing their views but do so with incredible conviction, passion and certainty. And yet, nutrition is anything but certain.  Sure, we know there are patterns of eating that help in minimizing the risk of various chronic diseases, but those patterns are far broader and less drilled down than most nutrition gurus and zealots believe.

So, we were very interested in fellow blogger –Yoni Freedhoff’s – recent blog in which he calls for an end of nutrition as religion.  More so, because Yoni is not just another disillusioned dieter. No siree!  He is the Medical Director of the Bariatric Medical Institute and assistant professor of family medicine at the University of Ottawa.  Dr. Freedhoff has also been called Canada’s most outspoken obesity expert and his award winning blog, Weighty Matters, has at times been ranked the world’s top health blog by blog ranking service Technorati.

So what does Dr Freedhoff have to say?

First, he suggests that practitioners of dietary religion risk alienating friends through strict adherence to their religious commandments.  Second, he states that diet adherents tend to use their online platform to frown upon any and all dietary strategies beyond their house of worship. To question their program or guru’s plans is akin to questioning their religious beliefs; and yet, unlike actual religious questioning (which would almost certainly lead to a thoughtful discussion), question dietary dogma online, and you can bet it will lead to a highly heated debate where anger and indignation can easily descend into name calling and personal attacks.

jesus toastAnd even if you religiously avoid all cyber nutrition nuts, you may still be at risk. According to Freedhoff, although you may not have a stranger’s zealous scrutiny to watch out for, you’ve still got yourself. Dietary dogma, almost by definition, dictates blind faith and absolute loyalty, where breaking a dietary commandment is akin to committing a sin. And with sin, comes guilt. And if you feel guilt often enough, you might well decide to abandon your entire healthier-living, guilt-inducing effort.

Nutrition as religion demands perfection, yet perfection is an impossible goal. Remember, food is not simply fuel. Since the dawn of humankind, food has been used for comfort and celebration, and if your newly found dietary religion forbids foods you enjoy, my bet is you’re not long for that diet.

diet tapemeasureSo what’s the solution?  Freedhoff advises : the easiest question to evaluate any dietary plan or religion is simply, “Could I happily live like this for the rest of my life?” where the most important word in that question is “happily.” If the answer’s “No,” you’ve either got to get comfortable with adding in some sinning, or find another way to go.

Add in some sinning in the form of thoughtful, “worth-it,” dietary imperfections, and suddenly new lifestyles may transform from the merely tolerable to the actually enjoyable. Enjoy your lifestyle, albeit imperfectly, and maybe you’ll even stick with it.

Nutrition isn’t religion. Eat the healthiest diet that you can enjoy, because if you’re not enjoying it, it isn’t going to last, and tolerable isn’t good enough.

Go on, sin a little, on us. The good doctor will forgive you enough to forgive yourself.

SRxA-logo for web

One thought on “A Call to End Religious Nutrition

  1. Interesting new research on the link between carbs and prostate cancer…
    New research shows men diagnosed with prostate cancer can make small dietary changes that are associated with their cancer survival and overall health.

    Researchers at the University of California, San Francisco, studied men diagnosed with prostate cancer. They found that replacing just 10 percent of carbohydrates with vegetable fats was associated with a 29 percent lower risk of death from prostate cancer and a 26 percent lower risk of death from other causes.

    “This study followed a large group of men with prostate cancer and surveyed them about their diets,” says oncologist Nima Sharifi, MD. “They found that the replacement of carbohydrates with vegetable fats was associated with a better outcome.”

    If you have been diagnosed with prostate cancer, Dr. Sharifi recommends a visit with a registered dietitian for help with improving your diet for overall health and longevity.

    The diet, prostate cancer link

    “This is new ground,” Dr. Sharifi says. “There are not a lot of data out there about the connection between diet and prostate cancer after diagnosis.”

    For 24 years, this study followed 4,500 men with prostate cancer and found that men who consumed a diet high in vegetable-based “healthy” fats were less likely to die of any cause, including prostate cancer.

    This is important news as prostate cancer touches so many lives; one out of every six men will be diagnosed during his lifetime. Thankfully, it’s also highly survivable, with 98 percent of men living at least 10 years after diagnosis.

    Questions and Answers About Prostate Cancer

    Saturated fat, trans fat and their effect

    In the research findings, vegetable-based “healthy” fats had a positive impact, but the opposite was also found to be true — a 5 percent increase in the intake of saturated fats (found in red meat) or 1 percent of trans fats (found in processed foods) was associated with a 25 percent to 30 percent higher risk of death from any cause.

    “Obesity is a risk factor for developing prostate cancer, so adopting a healthy diet is also critical for men to protect themselves against the disease,” Dr. Sharifi says.

    Low-fat confusion

    With the prevalence of food marketing equating “low-fat” with healthy, Dr. Sharifi acknowledges that the idea of choosing the right kind of fats to improve prostate cancer survival can be confusing.

    That’s why he encourages patients to see a certified dietitian who can help them adopt a diet that could boost their survival rates.

    “Diet does matter when it comes to prostate cancer, but we need more research to understand the impact and how men should modify their diets,” Dr. Sharifi says.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s